Good Homes. Good People.

I have known Sarah for over 30 years. She goes above and beyond in anything she does. As far as real estate goes she has sold five homes for my family and I and helped us purchase two homes and helped in the building process of two homes. Her expertise and knowledge has been a huge part in making these experiences go as smoothly as possible. If it wasn’t for the moving part of buying and selling I would keep her on speed dial and keep her busy every day. I am so excited for her new adventure and I know she will keep doing great things for our community.

Sarah helped me buy and re-sell my house. Both times were a very smooth process. She was patient with every question, comment, and concern. She bent over backwards to help both processes happen successfully. I highly recommend Sugar Key Realty for all of your realty needs.

I had a great experience selling my home and truly appreciated the professionalism and integrity throughout the process. Acting as both my listing agent and the buyer’s agent, she handled everything with fairness, transparency, and clear communication. I always felt that my best interests were represented while also ensuring a smooth and respectful experience for the buyers. Her knowledge of the market, attention to detail, and ability to manage both sides of the transaction made the entire process efficient and stress-free. I would absolutely recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Working with Sarah was such a great experience that I almost wish the process lasted longer—almost. From the start, her honesty stood out. She truly cared about helping us find the right home, not just any home, and was always upfront about the pros and cons of every property (including saving us from a few questionable choices). She consistently put our best interests first—even talking us out of homes she didn’t believe were a good deal or smart investment. That kind of integrity is rare and made us trust her completely. Her knowledge, attention to detail, and patience made everything feel easy and stress-free. If you want someone who genuinely cares and won’t settle for anything less than the right fit, I can’t recommend her enough.

We had Sarah as our realtor to sell our first home. 10/10 recommend! We were purchasing my FIL's home after he passed away but we needed to sell our home first. Our first home, that we renovated and did not intend on selling at that time. But this was important to us. I was terrified, there was no way everything was going to come together perfectly. We got ahold of Sarah and explained the situation. When we were ready to list a few weeks later, we had several showings on day one and accepted an offer the next night! The rest is a beautiful blur ♡

Working with Sarah was an absolutely wonderful experience from start to finish. She was incredibly responsive, always quick to answer questions and keep things moving smoothly. Her communication made the entire process feel easy and stress-free, which was something we truly appreciated. Sarah is not only professional and knowledgeable, but also genuinely kind and easy to work with. She took the time to understand what our family needed and helped us find the perfect home without making the process feel overwhelming. Everything was handled seamlessly, and we always felt confident that we were in great hands. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Sarah truly went above and beyond, and we would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

We had a fantastic experience with Sarah, we closed on our house really quickly, she was very through and had everything ready for us with no setbacks. She was very patient and understood what we were looking for when we looking for a first house. Would definitely use her again if needed but she found us the perfect house for a family of 5.

Sarah is amazing! We were first time home buyers and Sarah made our entire home buying process so seamless and she was extremely knowledgeable and friendly. I highly highly recommend her!

We can’t thank Sugar Key Realty enough for helping us find our dream home in Wisconsin. It’s exactly what we dreamed it would be – and we didn’t go over our budget! Sugar Key Realty local market knowledge, expertise, and amazing dedication made the whole buying process truly enjoyable. Thank you so much, Sugar Key Realty